Cover Page

Founded in 1807, John Wiley & Sons is the oldest independent publishing company in the United States. With offices in North America, Europe, Australia and Asia, Wiley is globally committed to developing and marketing print and electronic products and services for our customers' professional and personal knowledge and understanding.

The Wiley Finance series contains books written specifically for finance and investment professionals as well as sophisticated individual investors and their financial advisors. Book topics range from portfolio management to e-commerce, risk management, financial engineering, valuation and financial instrument analysis, as well as much more.

For a list of available titles, visit our Web site at www.WileyFinance.com.

Lessons in Corporate Finance

A Case Studies Approach to Financial Tools, Financial Policies, and Valuation




SECOND EDITION




PAUL ASQUITH

LAWRENCE A. WEISS









Wiley Logo

To those who taught me.

–Paul

For Marilyn, my wife and best friend; Joshua; and Daniel; all of whom I will love forever.

–Larry

About the Authors

Paul Asquith is the Gordon Y. Billard Professor of Finance at MIT's Sloan School, where he has been on the faculty for 30 years and is also a Research Associate of the National Bureau of Economic Research.

At the Sloan School, he served as Senior Associate Dean and as Chairman of Sloan's Building Committee. He teaches in the finance area, most recently Introduction to Corporate Finance. Professor Asquith has also developed and taught three other courses at MIT: Advanced Corporate Finance, Mergers and Acquisitions, and Security Design. He previously taught at Harvard University for 10 years, at the University of Chicago, and at Duke University. He is the recipient of 14 Teaching Excellence Awards from MIT, Harvard, and Duke. He is also the inaugural recipient of MIT's Jamieson Prize for Excellence in Teaching.

Professor Asquith received his BS from Michigan State University and his AM and PhD from the University of Chicago. A member of the American Accounting Association, the American Finance Association, and the Financial Management Association, Professor Asquith was regularly a discussant at financial conferences. In 1985, he spent one semester at Salomon Brothers while on sabbatical from Harvard University. Professor Asquith was formerly a Director of Aurora National Life Assurance Company. He has advised many corporations including Citicorp, IBM, Merck, Morgan Guaranty, Price Waterhouse, Royal Bank of Canada, Salomon Brothers, Toronto Dominion Bank, and Xerox, and has also served as an expert witness in both Federal Court and the Delaware Chancery Court.

Current research interests include regulated transparency in capital markets. His published articles include “Original Issue High Yield Bonds: Aging Analyses of Defaults, Exchanges, and Calls,” which won the 1989 Journal of Finance's Smith-Breeden award, and “Information Content of Equity Analyst Reports” in the Journal of Financial Economics, as well as several articles on corporate mergers, corporate dividend policy, the timing of corporate equity issues, stock splits, corporate call policy for convertible debt, and short sales in debt and equity markets. Professor Asquith was previously Associate Editor of the Journal of Financial Economics, the Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, and Financial Management. He was also director of the Financial Services Research Center at MIT.

Lawrence A. Weiss is Professor of International Accounting at Tufts University. Professor Weiss has taught introductory courses to advanced financial accounting as well as managerial accounting and finance courses. He previously taught at Georgetown University, IMD, HEC Lausanne, MIT's Sloan School, INSEAD, Tulane, Babson, and McGill University. He received the teacher of the year award while on the faculty of MIT and was repeatedly nominated for Best Professor at Tufts, INSEAD, and Tulane University.

Professor Weiss received his B. Com., Diploma in Public Accounting, and MBA from McGill University and his doctorate in Business Administration from Harvard University. He began his career as a Canadian Chartered Accountant (equivalent to a CPA in the United States) working for KPMG. A member of the American Accounting Association, he has been a discussant and has presented numerous papers. Professor Weiss is a recognized expert on U.S. corporate bankruptcy, and has testified before the U.S. Congress on bankruptcy reform. He has also advised corporations on their costing systems, and served as an expert witness in both civil and criminal cases.

Current research has three themes: the reorganization of financially distressed firms, operations management, and the transition from country-specific accounting standards (Local GAAP) to one set of global standards (IFRS). His published work includes “Bankruptcy Resolution: Direct Costs and Violation of Priority of Claims,” which won a Journal of Financial Economics All-Star Paper award; “Value Destruction in the New Era of Chapter 11” in the Journal of Law Economics and Organizations; and “On the Relationship between Inventory and Financial Performance in Manufacturing Companies,” in the International Journal of Operations Management. His book Corporate Bankruptcy: Economic and Legal Perspectives is published by Cambridge University Press. His two books Accounting for Fun and Profit: A Guide to Understanding Financial Statements (2016) and Accounting for Fun and Profit: A Guide to Understanding Advanced Topics in Accounting (2017) were published by Business Expert Press. Professor Weiss has also published op-eds in the New York Times, the (Toronto) Globe and Mail, and at HBR.org.

Acknowledgments

We both owe considerable debts to our instructors, in particular:

  • Paul wants to thank those who taught him finance and how to teach, especially Gene Fama, Milton Friedman, Al Mandelstamm, David W. Mullins Jr., Henry B. Reiling, and George Stigler.
  • Larry wants to thank those who taught him, especially Paul Asquith, Carliss Y. Baldwin, Roger C. Bennett, David Fewings, Michael Jensen, Robert Kaplan, Norman Keesal, Vivienne Livick, C. Harvey Rorke, and Howard H. Stevenson.
  • Paul and Larry also wish to thank Amar Bhide (Tufts University) and Laurent Jacque (Tufts University) for reading the book and for their many comments and suggestions. We are also grateful to Jacqueline Donnelly, Bridgette Hayes, Stephanie Landers, and Alison Wurtz who corrected many of our editorial mistakes and helped make our prose easier to read, and Michael Duh and Heidi Pickett, who helped ensure that our numbers are consistent. A special thanks is also owed to the John Wiley & Sons editorial team—most notably Tula Batanchiev, Elisha Benjamin, Michael Henton, Steven Kyritz, and Jayalakshmi Erkathil Thevarkandi for their guidance and enthusiasm.

Preface

On Tuesday, March 24, 2015, the share price of Google rose 2%, a roughly $8 billion increase in the value of the firm's equity. Was the large increase in Google's equity value because the firm's profits were up? No. Was the positive stock price reaction due to some good news about a new Google product? No. The reaction was due to Google's announcement that it was hiring Ruth Porat as its new chief financial officer (CFO). Why would the hiring of a new CFO cause Google's stock price to jump? According to the Wall Street Journal, Wall Street hoped the new CFO would bring “fiscal control at a company long known for its free spending ways.”1

Lessons in Corporate Finance is about the principal decisions in corporate finance (in other words, the decisions of CFOs like Google's Ruth Porat). These decisions focus on how to decide in which projects the firm should invest, how to finance those investments, and how to manage the firm's cash flows. This is an applied book that will use real-world examples to introduce the financial tools needed to make value-enhancing business decisions.

The book is designed to explain the how and why of corporate finance. While it is primarily aimed at finance professionals, it is also ideal for non-financial managers who have to deal with financial professionals. The book provides a detailed view of the inner functioning of corporate finance for anyone with an interest in understanding finance and what financial professionals do. The book would fit well in a second course in finance, as supplemental readings to an executive education course, or as a self-study book on corporate finance (e.g., for those studying for the CFA or similar certifications). The authors believe that any business professional, even someone with a degree in finance, will find the book to be a valuable review.

The second edition of the book differs from the first in two significant ways. The first is that there is new material throughout, including a new chapter (Chapter 13) on bankruptcy and restructuring. The new chapter covers the institutional rules (i.e., laws) and economics around firms that enter into financial distress and must restructure or file bankruptcy. It also covers the two principal sections of U.S. bankruptcy law.

The second, and more significant, change is in response to the 2018 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act passed in the United States in December 2017. This law took effect in January 2018 and represents a major change in the U.S. corporate tax code. Not only did it lower the maximum U.S. corporate tax rate from 35% to 21%, it also substantially altered the corporate tax shield from debt. The law reduces the advantages of debt financing and raises the cost of capital to many firms. This means the methodology used to value firms must also change substantially. These changes, and how to treat them, are covered throughout the book. Table 17.1 shows that these changes affect a substantial percentage of firms.

While this book can be read without extensive knowledge of accounting or finance, it is written for those with at least a basic knowledge of accounting and finance terminology.

NOTE

CHAPTER 1
Introduction

This book is a basic corporate finance text but unique in the way the subject is presented. The book's format involves asking a series of increasingly detailed questions about corporate finance decisions and then answering them with conceptual insights and specific numerical examples.

The book is structured around real-world decisions that a chief financial officer (CFO) must make: how firms obtain and use capital. The primary functions of corporate finance can be categorized into three main tasks:

  1. How to make good investment decisions
  2. How to make good financing decisions
  3. How to manage the firm's cash flows while doing the first two

Taking the last point first, cash is essential to a firm's survival. In fact, cash flow is much more important than earnings. A firm can survive bad products, ineffective marketing, and weak or even negative earnings and stay in business as long as it has cash flow. Not running out of cash is an essential part of corporate finance. It requires understanding and forecasting the nature and timing of a firm's cash flows. For example, at the turn of the century, dot-coms were almost all losing large sums of money. However, financial analysts covering these firms focused primarily not on earnings but on what is called “burn rates” (i.e., the rate at which a firm uses up or “burns” cash). There is an old saying in finance: “You buy champagne with your earnings, and you buy beer with your cash.” Cash is the day-to-day lifeblood of a firm. Another way to say this is that cash is like air, and earnings are like food. Although an organization needs both to survive, it can exist for a while without earnings but will die quickly without cash.

Turning to the first point, making good investment decisions means deciding where the firm should put (invest) its cash, that is, in what projects or products it should invest or produce. Investment decisions must answer this question: What are the future cash flows that result from current investment decisions?

Finally, making good financing decisions means deciding where the firm should obtain the cash for its investments. Financing decisions take the firm's investment decisions as a given and examine questions like: How should those investments be financed? Can value be created from the right-hand side of the Balance Sheet?

Thus, the CFO essentially does two things all day long with one constraint: make good investment decisions and make good financing decisions, while ensuring the firm does not run out of cash in between.

TWO MARKETS: PRODUCT AND CAPITAL

Every firm operates in two primary markets: the product market and the capital market. Firms can make money in either market. Most people understand a firm's role in the product market: to produce and sell goods or services at a price above cost. In contrast, the role of a firm in the capital markets is less well understood: to raise and invest funds to directly facilitate its activities in the product market.

When people think about capital markets, they typically focus on securities exchanges such as those for stocks, bonds, and options. However, this is only the supply side of capital markets. The other side is comprised of the users of capital: the firms themselves.

A crucial lesson when doing corporate finance is that financial strategy and product market strategy need to be consistent with one another. In addition, corporate finance spans both the product market through its investment decisions and the capital market through its financing decisions. When thinking about corporate finance, a firm must first determine its product market goals. Only then, once the product market goals are set, can management set its financial strategy and determine its financial policies.

Financial policies include the capital structure decision (i.e., the level of debt financing), the term structure of debt, the amount of secured and unsecured debt, whether the debt will have fixed or floating rates, the covenants attached to the debt, the amount (if any) of dividends it will pay, the amount and timing of equity issues and stock repurchases, and so on. Likewise, the firm's investment policies (e.g., to build or acquire, to do a leveraged buyout, a restructuring, a tender, a merger, etc.) are set in concert with the firm's product market strategy.

While it is critical for a firm to have a good product market strategy, its financial operations can also clearly add or destroy value. Value is created through the exploitation of a market imperfection in one of two markets:

  1. Product market imperfections include entry barriers, costs advantages, patents, and so on.
  2. Capital market imperfections involve financing at below-market rates, using innovative securities, reaching new investing clienteles, and the like.

In addition, the act of running the firm well can create or destroy value. Thus, we add point three:

  1. Managerial market imperfections include such considerations as agency costs (costs arising from the separation of ownership and control) and managers who are not doing a good job or self-dealing.

Without imperfections, there really is no corporate finance (a point we will explain in Chapter 6).

THE BASICS: TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES

This book teaches the basic tools and techniques of corporate finance, what they are, and how to apply them. It is, in football parlance, all about blocking and tackling. For example, ratios and working capital management are used as diagnostics as well as in the development of pro forma Income Statements and Balance Sheets, which are the backbone of valuation. It is not possible to do valuations without being able to do pro formas. This book will show readers how to determine financing needs, how to generate estimated cash flows, and then how to estimate the appropriate discount rate to convert the cash flows into a net present value.

Chapters 2 through 4 discuss cash flow management, which is essentially how to ensure the firm does not run out of cash. Cash flow management is necessary to evaluate the financial health of a firm, forecast financing needs, and value assets. The tools used in cash flow management include ratio analysis, pro forma statements, and the sources and uses of funds. This is the nitty-gritty of finance: managing and forecasting cash flows.

Chapters 5 through 13 examine how firms make good financing decisions. That is, how a firm should choose its capital structure and the trade-offs of the various financing alternatives. We will also cover financial policies and their impact on the cost of capital. These chapters will answer a number of questions, including: Can firms create value with their choice of financing? Is one type of financing superior to another? Should the firm use debt or equity? If the firm uses debt, should it be obtained from a bank or from the capital markets? Should it be short-term or long-term debt, convertible, callable? If the firm issues equity, should it be common stock or preferred stock? When should a firm restructure its liabilities and how?

Chapters 14 through 17 illustrate how firms make good investment decisions. The tools and techniques to value investment projects will be covered in depth, including the determination of the relevant cash flows and the appropriate discount rate. These tools and techniques will then be used to value projects and firms.

There are only five main techniques to value anything, four of which will be covered in this book (real options, the fifth method, will be covered only superficially because this technique is infrequently used and requires knowledge of options and mathematics beyond the scope of this book). This book will cover many different ways to value a firm or project within four main families or techniques. For example, discounted cash flow techniques include free cash flows to the firm with a weighted average cost of capital, using a free cash flow to equity discounted at the cost of equity, as well as calculating an adjusted present value (APV). Likewise, valuation multiples include using the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E), earnings before interest and tax (EBIT), and earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA), all of which are in the same family. The focus of the book is not only to teach the techniques but also to provide an understanding of the logic behind each method and to give readers the ability to translate from one valuation method to another.

Chapters 18 through 22 cover leveraged buyouts (LBOs), private equity, restructuring, bankruptcies, and mergers and acquisitions, all of which combine investment and financing decisions. These five chapters will use two comprehensive examples to cover the issues in depth.

Chapter 23 provides a review along with some of the authors' thoughts on both finance and life.

A DIAGRAM OF CORPORATE FINANCE

Figure 1.1 provides a schematic diagram of how your authors view corporate finance. Corporate finance begins with corporate strategy, which dictates both investment strategy and financial strategy. These strategies lead to investment and financial policies that ultimately have to be executed. We will emphasize many times in this book that there must be consistency between every level of this diagram. In addition, the investment and financial strategies and policies can create or destroy value for the firm. This book will cover the top three levels of Figure 1.1, illustrating the firm's financial strategies and policies.

Schematic illustration of the top three levels of Corporate Finance, covering a firm's financial strategies and policies.

FIGURE 1.1 Schematic of Corporate Finance

A BRIEF HISTORY OF MODERN FINANCE

Finance has changed a lot over the past 60 years, probably more than any other part of business schools' curricula. Modern finance really begins with Irving Fisher,1 who developed the use of present values in 1907, though the concept did not gain widespread dissemination in finance textbooks until the early 1950s. Another major advance in finance occurred in 1952 when Harry Markowitz2 developed portfolio theory, for which he won the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1990. Portfolio theory shows that diversification can reduce risk without reducing expected return. It is the theoretical basis for the mutual fund industry, which grew dramatically in the 1950s and 1960s.

Finance began to move away from payback as the principal technique to evaluate investments in the 1950s. Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and Net Present Value (NPV) took over as the primary ways to value investment decisions. The profession also moved away from believing earnings were of utmost importance. Today we know it is cash flows, not earnings, that matter most.

Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller (M&M) with their papers in 1958, 1961, and 1963 gave birth to modern corporate finance, which is the focus of this book. (Modigliani was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1985 for this and other work, while Miller was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1990 for this work.) M&M showed that under certain key assumptions, neither capital structure (1958) nor dividends (1961) mattered. In 1963, M&M relaxed their no-tax assumption and then capital structure mattered.

Other notable work we will call on in this book is that of Eugene Fama,3 who developed the concept of efficient markets in the 1960s (and won the Nobel Prize in 2013). His idea was that markets rapidly incorporate and price information. This concept was the demise of technical analysis, which still exists but has only a fringe following today.

Another major development in the 1960s was the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) created by William Sharpe and John Lintner. (Sharpe won the Nobel Prize in 1990 for this work. Lintner would have almost certainly shared the prize had he still been alive, but the Nobel is not awarded posthumously.4) The CAPM dramatically changed how we measure the performance of the stock market and other investments.

The next notable advance was the work done by Fischer Black, Myron Scholes, and Robert Merton on option pricing in the early 1970s. (Scholes and Merton received the Nobel Prize in 1997. Black died in 1995.) The extensive number of options trading today is based on this work.

Focusing specifically now on corporate finance, the M&M papers from 1958 to 1963 began to be modified and extended in the 1980s. Corporate finance theory moved beyond M&M by including elements such as asymmetric information, agency costs, and signaling. Theories developed in which capital structure and dividends did indeed matter. The interaction and dynamics between financing and investment decisions also became the subject of study.

More recently, finance has looked at the impact of human behavior in financial decisions. This is called behavioral finance, for which Richard Thaler won the 2017 Noble Prize, and returns to the question of whether markets are truly efficient and how individual behavior affects financial decisions.

On the institutional side, there were dramatic changes in the laws and institutions affecting corporate finance. In particular, regulations regarding new financing and commission rates on buying and selling equities dramatically changed corporate financing. For example, shelf registrations made the use of selling syndicates less common and underwriting far more competitive, so the number of investment banks dropped by more than half. At the same time, the size of the remaining major investment banks grew substantially.

The rise of the junk bond market began in 1988 and extended through the 1990s. Prior to 1988 it was virtually impossible to issue debt that was not investment grade (BBB or better). Lower-rated debt existed, but this was debt that had been investment grade when issued and had become riskier as the firm's financial situation deteriorated. (This risky debt was called “fallen angels.”) Michael Milken at the investment bank Drexel Burnham Lambert created a market where lower-rated (high-yield or “junk”) debt could be issued. This type of debt was used primarily to finance takeovers and start-ups. This dramatically changed the nature of corporate control as well.

The 1990s also saw the rise of hedge funds, the rapid increase of short sales, and a “stock market bubble” based on the overvaluation of dot-coms. The passage and adoption of the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010 has had and will continue to have a major impact on financial structures and practices. Most recently, the Jobs and Tax Cuts Act of 2018 was passed in December 2017. This was the most significant change to corporate tax law in at least 50 years. It not only reduced the maximum corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 21 percent, but it also limited the tax deductibility of interest and changed how capital expenditures are depreciated.

What is the next best big thing in finance? We wish we knew. New knowledge is rarely predictable.

READING THIS BOOK

While someone with no business background can read this book, it is designed for those with some prior knowledge of basic finance and accounting and will be much easier to read for that audience.

This book is written in a conversational format and uses a case-teaching, inductive approach. That is, examples are used to illustrate theory. While simply stating the theory as in a lecture format may be more direct, the use of examples provides the reader with a better understanding of the problem.

The footnotes don't have to be read the first time through a chapter, but they are meant to be read. They add important caveats, details, occasional humor, and examples of alternative ways to do the calculations in this book.

Repetition is an important part of learning any material and is an important part of this book. To that end, the tools and concepts in this book will be presented repeatedly, albeit in new and different situations. For example, ratio analysis, presented in the next chapter, will be used throughout the book. Every important topic will be mentioned several times in different contexts.

The material may seem difficult and even frustrating at first, but as readers proceed through the text, it will appear to slow down and come together. By the end of the book, readers should be able to understand how firms set financial policies and how valuation and investing is done in finance (e.g., read an investment bank valuation and understand the assumptions that were made, what is hidden, and what is not).

Like much in life, the best way to learn something is by doing it. Reading about how finance should and should not be done can teach up to a point. However, to really be able to do something yourself requires actually doing it. To that end, the reader is strongly encouraged to work through all the detailed examples and cases given in the book.

One brief comment on computer spreadsheets. The use of computer spreadsheets is very common today due to their facilitation in processing large quantities of data and their flexibility in allowing the user to change one item and see the impact elsewhere. Unfortunately, the use of computer spreadsheets often causes the user to lose any sense of the underlying assumptions. For this reason, it is often useful to fall back on paper and pencil when doing an analysis for the first time.

Finally, in most situations there are definite wrong answers, but there is generally more than one right answer.

After reading the book, we hope you will have enjoyed yourself and learned a lot of finance.

Welcome aboard!

NOTES

PART One
Financial Health of a Firm and Cash Flow Management